PHP: Spotting References

Spotting References

Many syntax constructs in PHP are implemented via referencing mechanisms, so everything mentioned herein about reference binding also applies to these constructs. Some constructs, like passing and returning by reference, are mentioned above. Other constructs that use references are:

global References

When you declare a variable as global $var you are in fact creating reference to a global variable. That means, this is the same as:

<?php

$var =& $GLOBALS["var"];

?>

This also means that unsetting $var won't unset the global variable.

Improve This Page

Learn How To Improve This Page • Submit a Pull Request • Report a Bug

＋add a note

User Contributed Notes 8 notes

down

BenBE at omorphia dot de ¶

17 years ago

Hi,

If you want to check if two variables are referencing each other (i.e. point to the same memory) you can use a function like this:

<?php

function same_type(&$var1, &$var2){
    return gettype($var1) === gettype($var2);
}

function is_ref(&$var1, &$var2) {
    //If a reference exists, the type IS the same
    if(!same_type($var1, $var2)) {
        return false;
    }

    $same = false;

    //We now only need to ask for var1 to be an array ;-)
    if(is_array($var1)) {
        //Look for an unused index in $var1
        do {
            $key = uniqid("is_ref_", true);
        } while(array_key_exists($key, $var1));

        //The two variables differ in content ... They can't be the same
        if(array_key_exists($key, $var2)) {
            return false;
        }

        //The arrays point to the same data if changes are reflected in $var2
        $data = uniqid("is_ref_data_", true);
        $var1[$key] =& $data;
        //There seems to be a modification ...
        if(array_key_exists($key, $var2)) {
            if($var2[$key] === $data) {
                $same = true;
            }
        }

        //Undo our changes ...
        unset($var1[$key]);
    } elseif(is_object($var1)) {
        //The same objects are required to have equal class names ;-)
        if(get_class($var1) !== get_class($var2)) {
            return false;
        }

        $obj1 = array_keys(get_object_vars($var1));
        $obj2 = array_keys(get_object_vars($var2));

        //Look for an unused index in $var1
        do {
            $key = uniqid("is_ref_", true);
        } while(in_array($key, $obj1));

        //The two variables differ in content ... They can't be the same
        if(in_array($key, $obj2)) {
            return false;
        }

        //The arrays point to the same data if changes are reflected in $var2
        $data = uniqid("is_ref_data_", true);
        $var1->$key =& $data;
        //There seems to be a modification ...
        if(isset($var2->$key)) {
            if($var2[$key] === $data) {
                $same = true;
            }
        }

        //Undo our changes ...
        unset($var1->$key);
    } elseif (is_resource($var1)) {
        if(get_resource_type($var1) !== get_resource_type($var2)) {
            return false;
        }

        return ((string) $var1) === ((string) $var2);
    } else {
        //Simple variables ...
        if($var1!==$var2) {
            //Data mismatch ... They can't be the same ...
            return false;
        }

        //To check for a reference of a variable with simple type
        //simply store its old value and check against modifications of the second variable ;-)

        do {
            $key = uniqid("is_ref_", true);
        } while($key === $var1);

        $tmp = $var1; //WE NEED A COPY HERE!!!
        $var1 = $key; //Set var1 to the value of $key (copy)
        $same = $var1 === $var2; //Check if $var2 was modified too ...
        $var1 = $tmp; //Undo our changes ...
    }

    return $same;
}

?>

Although this implementation is quite complete, it can't handle function references and some other minor stuff ATM.
This function is especially useful if you want to serialize a recursive array by hand.

The usage is something like:
<?php
$a = 5;
$b = 5;
var_dump(is_ref($a, $b)); //false

$a = 5;
$b = $a;
var_dump(is_ref($a, $b)); //false

$a = 5;
$b =& $a;
var_dump(is_ref($a, $b)); //true
echo "---\n";

$a = array();
var_dump(is_ref($a, $a)); //true

$a[] =& $a;
var_dump(is_ref($a, $a[0])); // true
echo "---\n";

$b = array(array());
var_dump(is_ref($b, $b)); //true
var_dump(is_ref($b, $b[0])); //false
echo "---\n";

$b = array();
$b[] = $b;
var_dump(is_ref($b, $b)); //true
var_dump(is_ref($b, $b[0])); //false
var_dump(is_ref($b[0], $b[0][0])); //true*
echo "---\n";

var_dump($a);
var_dump($b);

?>

* Please note the internal behaviour of PHP that seems to do the reference assignment BEFORE actually copying the variable!!! Thus you get an array containing a (different) recursive array for the last testcase, instead of an array containing an empty array as you could expect.

BenBE.

down

ludvig dot ericson at gmail dot com ¶

18 years ago

For the sake of clarity:

$this is a PSEUDO VARIABLE - thus not a real variable. ZE treats is in other ways then normal variables, and that means that some advanced variable-things won't work on it (for obvious reasons):

<?php
class Test {
    var $monkeys = 0;
    
    function doFoobar() {
        $var = "this";
        $$var->monkeys++; // Will fail on this line.
    }
}

$obj = new Test;
$obj->doFoobar(); // Will fail in this call.
var_dump($obj->monkeys); // Will return int(0) if it even reaches here.
?>

down

ksamvel at gmail dot com ¶

18 years ago

One may check reference to any object by simple operator==( object). Example:



<?php

  class A {}



  $oA1 = new A();



  $roA = & $oA1;



  echo "roA and oA1 are " . ( $roA == $oA1 ? "same" : "not same") . "<br>";



  $oA2 = new A();

  $roA = & $roA2;



  echo "roA and oA1 are " . ( $roA == $oA1 ? "same" : "not same") . "<br>";

?>



Output:



roA and oA1 are same

roA and oA1 are not same



Current technique might be useful for caching in objects when inheritance is used and only base part of extended class should be copied (analog of C++: oB = oA):



<?php

class A { 

  /* Any function changing state of A should set $bChanged to true */

  public function isChanged() { return $this->bChanged; }

  private $bChanged;

  //...

}



class B extends A {

// ...

  public function set( &$roObj) {

    if( $roObj instanceof A) {

      if( $this->roAObj == $roObj &&

          $roObj->isChanged()) {

        /* Object was not changed do not need to copy A part of B */

      } else {

        /* Copy A part of B */

        $this->roAObj = &$roObj;

      }

    }

  }



  private $roAObj;

}

?>

down

Sergio Santana: ssantana at tlaloc dot imta dot mx ¶

19 years ago

Sometimes an object's method returning a reference to itself is required. Here is a way to code it:

<?php
class MyClass {
  public $datum;
  public $other;
  
  function &MyRef($d) { // the method
    $this->datum = $d;
    return $this; // returns the reference
  }
}

$a = new MyClass;
$b = $a->MyRef(25); // creates the reference

echo "This is object \$a: \n";
print_r($a);
echo "This is object \$b: \n";
print_r($b);

$b->other = 50;

echo "This is object \$a, modified" .
     " indirectly by modifying ref \$b: \n";
print_r($a);
?>

This code outputs:
This is object $a:
MyClass Object
(
    [datum] => 25
    [other] =>
)
This is object $b:
MyClass Object
(
    [datum] => 25
    [other] =>
)
This is object $a, modified indirectly by modifying ref $b:
MyClass Object
(
    [datum] => 25
    [other] => 50
)

down

Sergio Santana: ssantana at tlaloc dot imta dot mx ¶

18 years ago

*** WARNING about OBJECTS TRICKY REFERENCES ***
-----------------------------------------------
The use of references in the context of classes
and objects, though well defined in the documentation,
is somehow tricky, so one must be very careful when
using objects. Let's examine the following two
examples:

<?php
  class y {
    public $d;
  }
  
  $A = new y;
  $A->d = 18;
  echo "Object \$A before operation:\n";
  var_dump($A);
  
  $B = $A; // This is not an explicit (=&) reference assignment,
           // however, $A and $B refer to the same instance 
           // though they are not equivalent names
  $C =& $A; // Explicit reference assignment, $A and $C refer to 
            // the same instance and they have become equivalent
            // names of the same instance
  
  $B->d = 1234;
 
  echo "\nObject \$B after operation:\n";
  var_dump($B);
  echo "\nObject \$A implicitly modified after operation:\n";
  var_dump($A); 
  echo "\nObject \$C implicitly modified after operation:\n";
  var_dump($C); 
  
  // Let's make $A refer to another instance
  $A = new y;
  $A->d = 25200;
  echo "\nObject \$B after \$A modification:\n";
  var_dump($B); // $B doesn't change
  echo "\nObject \$A after \$A modification:\n";
  var_dump($A); 
  echo "\nObject \$C implicitly modified after \$A modification:\n";
  var_dump($C); // $C changes as $A changes
?>

Thus, note the difference between assignments $X = $Y and $X =& $Y.
When $Y is anything but an object instance, the first assignment means
that $X will hold an independent copy of $Y, and the second, means that
$X and $Y will refer to the same thing, so they are tight together until 
either $X or $Y is forced to refer to another thing. However, when $Y 
happens to be an object instance, the semantic of $X = $Y changes and 
becomes only slightly different to that of $X =& $Y, since in both
cases $X and $Y become references to the same object. See what this
example outputs:

Object $A before operation:
object(y)#1 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(18)
}

Object $B after operation:
object(y)#1 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(1234)
}

Object $A implicitly modified after operation:
object(y)#1 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(1234)
}

Object $C implicitly modified after operation:
object(y)#1 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(1234)
}

Object $B after $A modification:
object(y)#1 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(1234)
}

Object $A after $A modification:
object(y)#2 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(25200)
}

Object $C implicitly modified after $A modification:
object(y)#2 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(25200)
}

Let's review a SECOND EXAMPLE:
<?php
  class yy {
    public $d;
    function yy($x) {
      $this->d = $x;
    }
  }

  function modify($v)
  {
     $v->d = 1225;
  }

  $A = new yy(3);
  var_dump($A); 
  modify($A);
  var_dump($A);
?>

Although, in general, a formal argument declared 
as $v in the function 'modify' shown above, implies
that the actual argument $A, passed when calling 
the function, is not modified, this is not the 
case when $A is an object instance. See what the
example code outputs when executed:

object(yy)#3 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(3)
}
object(yy)#3 (1) {
  ["d"]=>
  int(1225)
}

down

CodeWorX.ch ¶

13 years ago

here is an unconventional (and not very fast) way of detecting references within arrays:

<?php

    function is_array_reference ($arr, $key) {
        $isRef = false;
        ob_start();
        var_dump($arr);
        if (strpos(preg_replace("/[ \n\r]*/i", "", preg_replace("/( ){4,}.*(\n\r)*/i", "", ob_get_contents())), "[" . $key . "]=>&") !== false)
            $isRef = true;
        ob_end_clean();
        return $isRef;
    }

?>

down

biziclop ¶

7 months ago

Here is another function for checking if two variables refer to each other.
The function by BenBE works properly, but it's very long and maybe slow.
This is a shorter, faster and hopefully bug-free alternative.
Works at least from PHP 4.3.0 to 8.3.4: https://3v4l.org/5JNSl

<?php

function is_same_ref( & $a, & $b ){
  // Save original values
  $ori_a = $a;
  $ori_b = $b;
  // Give them different values
  $a = 1;
  $b = 2;
  // Compare them, if they're equal, they are references to each other
  $eq = $a === $b;
  // Restore original values
  $a = $ori_a;
  $b = $ori_b;
  return $eq;
}

$a = array(1,2);
$b =& $a;
$c =& $a;  // to check for side effects
var_dump( is_same_ref( $a, $b ));
// bool(true)

$a[] = 3;
$b[] = 4;
// After juggling our array in various ways inside is_same_ref(),
// all three variables still refer to the very same array:
var_dump( implode( $a ), implode( $b ), implode( $c ));
// string(4) "3456"
// string(4) "3456"
// string(4) "3456"
?>

down

-1

Abimael Rodrguez Coln ¶

13 years ago

This is one way to check if is a reference
<?php
$a = 1;
$b =& $a;
$c = 2;
$d = 3;
$e = array($a);
function is_reference($var){
    $val = $GLOBALS[$var];
    $tmpArray = array();
    /**
     * Add keys/values without reference
     */
    foreach($GLOBALS as $k => $v){
        if(!is_array($v)){
            $tmpArray[$k] = $v;
        }
    }

    /**
     * Change value of rest variables
     */
    foreach($GLOBALS as $k => $v){
        if($k != 'GLOBALS'
            && $k != '_POST'
            && $k != '_GET'
            && $k != '_COOKIE'
            && $k != '_FILES'
            && $k != $var
            && !is_array($v)
        ){
            usleep(1);
            $GLOBALS[$k] = md5(microtime());
        }
    }

    $bool = $val != $GLOBALS[$var];

    /**
     * Restore defaults values
     */
    foreach($tmpArray as $k => $v){
        $GLOBALS[$k] = $v;
    }

    return $bool;
}
var_dump(is_reference('a'));
var_dump(is_reference('b'));
var_dump(is_reference('c'));
var_dump(is_reference('d'));
?>

This won't check if reference is inside a array.

＋add a note